The joyous holiday season is fast approaching upon the gang. Cole was initially supposed to play Santa Claus for Tommy's Big Brothers Program annual Christmas party, but an emergency at the airport has unfortunelately held him up. Obviously not going to be able to make it in time, and with the group of young anxious kids present there quickly getting restless, Martin is by reqest forced to reluctantly agree to dress up as Santa for the occasion. He tells the kids his own version of the 'First Christmas Story', in which Martin and his friends are imagined reenacting the birth of Christ.